Hate in Context

Week 10: Reducing Hate Crime II — Persuasion · LENS preview

Violeta Haas

Department of Political Science

School of Social Sciences and Philosophy

Trinity College Dublin

This Week

  1. Catch-up: Week 9
  2. Persuasion
  3. Exercise: At the Christmas Table
  4. Strategies
  5. Synthesis
  6. Outlook

Catch-up: Week 9

The perfect Experiment

Design a hypothetical (para)social contact experiment to reduce prejudice/discrimination. Imagine unlimited resources (monetary, time, and (wo)manpower).

1
2
3
4
5

Your task (groups of 3–4)

  • Design a research poster for your experiment.
    1. Title + RQ
    2. Short description (including setting + sample)
    3. Design: treatment, control & randomization
    4. Outcomes (include attitudinal + behavioral)
    5. Are (para)social contact criteria met and how?
  • Each group picks one person to pitch (2 min).
  • Vote on the best Experiment!

Collect notes (5 min)

If you were here last week

  1. Collect your notes from the poster.
  2. Decide who will pitch (2 minutes).

If you missed last week

  1. What are internal and external validity in experiments?
  2. What does scalability mean for experimental interventions?

Your turn!

Vote on the best Experiment!

QR code to submit vote

on Blackboard → Week 10 → POU44653 Week 10: Vote on the best Experiment

Internal / external validity and scalability

[discussed in class]

Persuasion

Why is it so difficult to persuade people?

Why persuasion fails

Kalla & Broockman (2020) argue that people often resist persuasion because:

  1. Admitting error: changing one’s mind means conceding that prior views were wrong
  2. Identity protection: social identity theory — attitudes often affirm valued group memberships (e.g. partisanship); contrary views threaten that identity, so people defend the attitude to protect the self
  3. Autonomy / reactance: people dislike feeling manipulated — so they counter-argue or dismiss messages

Exercise: At the Christmas Table

A set Christmas dinner table with crackers, plates, and wine glasses

At the Christmas Table

It’s Christmas time — we all know what that means! Turkey, wine… and Uncle Seán bringing up immigration again. He’s repeatedly expressed anti-immigrant sentiments. Your job: try to have a better conversation than last year — and persuade Uncle Seán to rethink his exclusionary attitudes.

[discussed in class]

Your task (groups of 3–4, ≈20–25 min)

  1. Decide on a strategy from the readings — which ones seemed to work, and why?
  2. Open the chatbot (Blackboard) and try that approach with Seán.
  3. When you’re finished, click Ask for debrief for your score.
  4. Download your conversation.

Rules: max 10 turns; you may restart the chat once.

Also on Blackboard → Week 10 → Uncle Seán

Which approach did you take and did it work?